- Tinkercad vs 123d design how to#
- Tinkercad vs 123d design software#
- Tinkercad vs 123d design series#
- Tinkercad vs 123d design free#
* In TinkerCad, mouse movement rotates the viewpoint, and Shift + mouse movement pans the camera. In 123D Design, holding down Shift does nothing mouse movement still rotates the viewpoint. The biggest problem I'm seeing so far is that while 123D Design has all of TinkerCad's functionality, the UI is quite different. is stability a significant problem?), so that's off-putting, but otherwise it was OK. The app crashed once about five minutes in (er. Having spent about ten minutes with 123D Design - so far, I like what I see. But, you're quite right - that seems like an illusion.I've been using TinkerCad heavily for a few months, and today I decided to give 123D Design a shot - specifically because the UI looks very similar to TinkerCad, just taken to the next level.
Tinkercad vs 123d design software#
I'm not asking for the ability to create assemblies of aircraft engines here.but I feel like, the way the software is advertised, I should be able to use it to do something useful like design a cell phone holder for the dashboard of my car, that I can then print at home. I guess this is OK for cutesey little 3D printed trinkets, but that makes it completely useless for something like a simple angle bracket where you need exact dimensions for the diameter/location of holes. In any other parametric CAD program you'd be able to define the location of the center of that circle relative to the edges of the rectangle but he just drags it around until it looks centered.
Tinkercad vs 123d design how to#
I took one look at it and thought "Ah! Look how nicely that whole assembly fits together! This guy must know what he's doing, hopefully these videos will explain how to do this properly".only to watch a few of them and find out that he was freehanding/eyeballing the whole thing.Ĭoncrete example - at about the 4:15 mark in that video, he draws a circle (to extrude a cylinder) on top of an existing rectangular face.
Tinkercad vs 123d design series#
I also had a brief panic moment that I was already too old and curmudgeonly to easily pick up new software (I'm 27).įor example, I found this Instructable with a series of tutorial videos like this one. It looks like we're not alone (I got a comment from another engineer on an forum who agreed 123D was "infuriating to use").
Tinkercad vs 123d design free#
the center of the hole is defined by two distances from perpendicular edges of the bracket), seems impossible.ġ) I'm just being lazy/impatient and need to look at more tutorials for the programs (although all of the tutorials I've seen so far seem to be more about qualitatively clicking and dragging things around, not entering exact dimensions)Ģ) I'm just spoiled from using professional-grade software, and really need to scale back my expectations for what these free programs can do.Īny insight would be appreciated.especially if you can point me to a good tutorial for something like designing a bracket with exact dimensions in 123D. For example, just creating a simple right-angle bracket with holes in certain locations (e.g. But, as far as I can tell, it's remarkably difficult if not impossible to set the dimensions of each new feature relative to each other beyond clumsily clicking and dragging them around, or some basic "snap together" functions. Generally, I get that most of them let you create 3D shape primitives (rectangular prisms, cylinders etc) and set their dimensions. I've tried Autodesk 123D Design, TinkerCAD, and Google Sketchup - and the result is that I just get immediately infuriated at (what I perceive as) the very limited functionality of these programs. Recently I tried to pick up using a free consumer CAD program for use with my home 3D printer. I have ~7 years of experience using Solidworks.
0 kommentar(er)
